« Killing Condos | Main | What if Health Care Reform Never Happens? »
Jun 22 2009, 3:56 pm by Megan McArdle
Steve Jobs Is Very, Very Sick
Orac has some extended explanation. Key points:
1) Steve Jobs' wealth and power let him jump the queue for organ transplants in a way that even I am uncomfortable with--and I am in favor of paying organ donors.
2) The transplant is highly controversial with an unknown success rate
3) There's a pretty good chance that in the next five years, we'll find out whether CEOs matter--at least to Apple.
Comments (4)
Today's Headlines From The Atlantic
books Books of the Year
The 25 best in a crowded field
college football Ground War
Army's best option to finally beat Navy
borders Tijuana of the Caspian
Sex, booze, revolution on sale near Iran
- The Sunday Shows in Five Bullet Points
- Top 5 Sunday Columns
- Politics Beats Science in Cancer Screening Debate
VOICES
Wonderwoman 11.22.09 6:50 P.M.
Oprah Winfrey Ending the Most Successful Television Sh… 11.20.09 2:04 P.M.
Did The Chinese Watch Obamas Town Hall? 11.22.09 2:13 P.M.
NFL Open Thread 11.22.09 11:57 A.M.
Rhodes pushback 11.22.09 11:27 P.M.
Sarah Palin and the Rapture 11.20.09 1:23 P.M.
How to do a second stimulus 11.20.09 1:27 A.M.
Ohio Jumps On The Rating Agency Lawsuit Bandwagon
Fed Audit Legislation Progresses
How Inaccurate GDP Figures Can Lead to Inflation
Oprah Winfrey Ending the Most Successful Television Show Ever
Megan McArdle on Health Care, Debt and Obama
Megan McArdle of Atlantic Business debates The New Republic's Noam Scheiber on Bloggingheads....
Video
Larry Summers on the Global Economy
Video
Eric Schmidt on the Future of the Internet
Video
Is Obama Anti-Business?
Weekly
Author
- Arnold Kling
- Anal_yst
- Ben Adler
- Bob Cohn
- Benjamin Lockwood
- Ben Bradley
- Bart Wilson
- Conor Clarke
- Clive Crook
- Charles Davi
- Conor Friedersdorf
- Chris Good
- Cyra Master
- Clement Tan
- Daniel Indiviglio
- Derek Lowe
- Dr. Manhattan
- Derek Thompson
- Economics of Contempt
- Eric Werker
- Francis X. McArdle
- Gregory Clark
- Grant McCracken
- Graeme Wood
- Harvey Wallbanger
- James Fallows
- James Gibney
- J.J. Gould
- Joshua Green
- Jim Manzi
- Jenny Merkin
- Justin Miller
- Jeffrey Young
- Kerry Golds
- Marc Ambinder
- Matthew Cooper
- Mindles H. Dreck
- Megan Hupp
- Max Fisher
- Madeleine Kennedy
- Michael Kinsley
- Megan McArdle
- Matt Miller
- Marion Nestle
- Mike Konczal
- Niraj Chokshi
- Paul Ormerod
- Peter Suderman
- Rob Atkinson
- Ryan Avent
- Ross Douthat
- Richard Florida
- Regina Herzlinger
- Richard A. Posner
- Reihan Salam
- Steven Landsburg
- Tyler Cowen
- Virginia Postrel
- William Haseltine
- Nina and Tim Zagat
Monthly
Category
Home |
Atlantic FAQ |
Masthead |
Site Guide |
Subscribe |
Subscriber Help
Atlantic Store |
Educational Program |
Jobs/Internships |
Privacy Policy |
Terms and Conditions |
Feedback |
Advertise
Copyright © 2009 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All rights reserved.






Thank goodness I took the time to read the entire article from Orac and the comments on that page. The extrapolation above does not do just to the essence of the explanation, nor does it give enough emphasis to the fact that Orac is supposing a lot based on a very limited data set. I am not sure what the purpose of this distillation is, but it does not accurately reflect the original writer's thesis in my humble opinion.
It wasn't Jobs' wealth and power that put him in front of the transplant line, it was our need for his incredible visionary mind. His type only presents a civilization with a few in a lifetime. If Einstein had cancer and we could have saved him for the sake of our space race for example, would you be bitter about it? Instead, I see the value in saving a mind such as his. And I've never met him, don't know him, don't work for him, only know what I read.
Deborah Calvert, Newport Beach, California
Incredible visionary mind? Dude is a businessman. It's not like he's out there devising cures to cancer or unlocking the secrets of DNA. He's making a (a few) bucks. To put him on par with Einstein isn't a bit of a stretch. It's pulling an Evel Knievel.
On second reading, perhaps your post was satire. If so, I apologize.
Steve Jobs reported for work today, Sept. 22nd. His cancer is slow growing and a liver transplant can yield a long life. Liver transplants have a 75% chance of 5 years added lifespan. Liver transplants are normally done for other, more threatening diseases. It is rare for anyone with metastasized tumors to be approved for transplants. Jobs' tumor is an exception. Tennessee has a short waiting period for liver transplants so the speculation of Jobs jumping over anyone is likely false as his transplant was likely requested in January and the operation done in March. Tennessee's wait is about 48 days. A cancer surgeon in Stanford, CA said today that such transplants in Jobs' case were quite successful.
Why can someone with the urge to post on Jobs can fail to find such commonly available information counter to the content posted leads one to believe that opinion or macabre humor was the driving force behind the drivel.