« Is What's Good for Pharma Good for America? | Main | Why Economics Failed »
Aug 17 2009, 11:00 am
Why is Asia Dominating in the World Recovery?
As the United States and Western Europe beam about our glacial recoveries ("Look everybody, 0.1 percent annualized negative growth last quarter!"), Asia must be pointing and laughing a good, boastful laugh. Six months after the nadir of this global near-depression, Asia is dominating, again. As the old G7 risks contracting 3 percent this year, Asia could grow by 5 percent. China, Indonesia, South Korea and Singapore grew by an average annualized rate of 10 percent last quarter. Even Japan, where first-quarter GDP fell at a worlds-worst annualized rate of 11.7 percent, recently recorded positive growth in the second quarter.
Why?
The Economist, of course, has done a bang-up job following Asia's economic moon-bounce. They say the Asian recovery is the product of four things.
1) Huge government stimulus
Japan, having learned its lesson from the Lost Decade to counter recessions with speed and vigor, unleashed a stimulus that amounted to 5 percent of GDP, about the same as the US. China's stimulus (more than 12 percent of GDP, by some reports) has been spent much faster than ours.
2) Low debt
One reason many American economists are worried that our stimulus won't juice consumer spending is that American need the money to get out of debt, not to buy new clothes and furniture. But many Asian countries are famous savers. The continent is swimming in liquidity and some are wondering whether countries like China will recalibrate their economy to make consumption a much larger part of their their economy.
3) Healthier banks
This is a simple one: Many Asian banks were not nearly as tainted by the mortgage-backed securities and credit default swaps that took Western investment banks, hedge funds and insurance companies. When the world economy fell, they fell too, but onto a higher floor.
4) Manufacturing's comeback
During a recession, many Asian-based products like electronics are the first to go. But as the world economy gets back on track, consumers are returning to their techie wish lists and Asian manufacturing is clicking again.
Why?
The Economist, of course, has done a bang-up job following Asia's economic moon-bounce. They say the Asian recovery is the product of four things.
1) Huge government stimulus
Japan, having learned its lesson from the Lost Decade to counter recessions with speed and vigor, unleashed a stimulus that amounted to 5 percent of GDP, about the same as the US. China's stimulus (more than 12 percent of GDP, by some reports) has been spent much faster than ours.
2) Low debt
One reason many American economists are worried that our stimulus won't juice consumer spending is that American need the money to get out of debt, not to buy new clothes and furniture. But many Asian countries are famous savers. The continent is swimming in liquidity and some are wondering whether countries like China will recalibrate their economy to make consumption a much larger part of their their economy.
3) Healthier banks
This is a simple one: Many Asian banks were not nearly as tainted by the mortgage-backed securities and credit default swaps that took Western investment banks, hedge funds and insurance companies. When the world economy fell, they fell too, but onto a higher floor.
4) Manufacturing's comeback
During a recession, many Asian-based products like electronics are the first to go. But as the world economy gets back on track, consumers are returning to their techie wish lists and Asian manufacturing is clicking again.










What's alarming to me is the pace of Asian development in future infrastructure investments, like solar, high speed rail, and even fiber (to our detriment), while we're patching our crumbling 1950's style highways and bridges and figuring out how to keep GM going a few years longer. We're still wasting time over ideological issues like whether government should be bigger or smaller, how we should pay for healthcare, who should have an assault rifle, and where, while they're building 21st information age economies. I get the disturbing feeling that except for Silicon Valley (and Google), we're getting further and further behind, moving backwards in our race to the bottom.